# The Value of Misguided Beliefs: Lessons from Miasma Theory
Written on
Understanding Miasma Theory
One of my favorite historical narratives revolves around the miasma theory, which posited that diseases were caused by "bad air." The term "miasma" originates from ancient Greek, meaning "pollution," while its more common Italian counterpart, "malaria," translates to "bad air."
As you might suspect, malaria was once believed to stem from this noxious air. This theory dominated the understanding of disease from ancient times in both Europe and China. Renowned figures like Hippocrates and Galen subscribed to the miasma theory, which advocated for disease prevention through the avoidance of foul air—a belief that persisted until the late 19th century.
In the late 1800s, germ theory began to take precedence, marking a significant advancement in medical science. However, it’s important to recognize that miasma theory wasn’t entirely misguided. Unlike bloodletting—a bizarre and harmful practice thought to aid ailing patients—miasma theory was based on sensible observations and still offers insights today.
The Role of Correlation in Belief
Humans excel at recognizing correlations between events. Philosopher David Hume suggested that what we often regard as "knowledge" is merely a collection of habits formed by consistently observing these correlations. While correlation does not imply causation, it is a primary driver of our beliefs.
With miasma theory, individuals frequently observed links between foul odors and illness. They noted that certain diseases, such as malaria, were more prevalent near swamps and that sickness often followed the presence of decaying organic matter, like refuse and corpses. This reasoning is illustrated in the artwork featured at the beginning of this piece, which reflects the common understanding that battles led to numerous fatalities, subsequently increasing cholera cases. The association between illness and unpleasant smells was particularly evident during outbreaks of the bubonic plague.
The miasma perspective logically deduced that if ailments like cholera, malaria, and plague were caused by contaminated air, the solution was to mitigate or eliminate these odors. This line of thinking prompted health officials and governments to take action, such as draining swamps, cleaning urban refuse, and ensuring untainted water supplies.
People’s knack for identifying correlations led them to observe that these interventions not only reduced foul smells but also decreased disease prevalence. Even though it was incorrect to believe that the elimination of bad air was the direct cause of reduced illness, the misguided belief proved to be beneficial, ultimately saving countless lives.
Why This Matters Today
Am I suggesting that we should embrace false ideas? Absolutely not. My intention is to caution against arrogance. Many individuals tend to overestimate their knowledge. As Hume highlighted, what we believe to be knowledge is often just a product of habit rather than genuine understanding. Those who identify as scientifically minded can be particularly prone to this hubris, often feeling superior to those in the past who subscribed to now-debunked theories.
While it’s true that we may possess a greater understanding of certain concepts than earlier generations, that doesn’t imply that those individuals were inherently less intelligent or uninformed. Much of our current knowledge will likely be replaced by new theories in the future. This cycle is a fundamental aspect of both science and everyday life, where all humans—across all eras—strive to comprehend the world by observing correlations and acting accordingly.
Friedrich Nietzsche, with his characteristic bluntness, asserted that even erroneous beliefs can hold value. Pragmatist philosophers maintain that the truth of an idea is rooted in its practical utility. Few concepts embody this principle more than the core tenet of pragmatism. We are all theorists reacting to the correlations we perceive in our surroundings. Arrogance—believing oneself to be all-knowing—is an obstacle to genuine learning and understanding. Miasma theory serves as a compelling reminder that humility and open-minded observation are far more effective strategies than dogmatic beliefs.
Exploring Historical Contexts
In the plague-ravaged London of 1665, could perfumes have truly been life-saving?
The Nature of Belief and Its Development
All we possess are beliefs, making it crucial to understand how we form them.
Thomas Kuhn and Science's Self-Perception
Challenging the inflated self-image often held by science.