Arsenic, the Powder of Inheritance

Ancient civilizations, including the Greeks, Romans, and Egyptians, were aware of various plant poisons. For instance, Socrates faced execution by hemlock in 399 BC. Over a millennium later, arsenic trioxide emerged as a potent inorganic poison, first synthesized by the Arab alchemist Geber.

The exact moment its toxic effects were identified remains a mystery. Countless victims have likely succumbed to arsenic over the ages, as this poison provided near-total immunity for its users due to its undetectability by early medical professionals and law enforcement. The only sign of foul play was the distinctive garlic-like scent that lingered around the deceased.

Among the famous figures rumored to be victims of arsenic poisoning was Napoleon Bonaparte, who spent his final days in exile on the island of Saint Helena. However, proof is elusive. Arsenic was often administered in minuscule amounts over extended periods, leading to symptoms that mimicked common ailments. Historians speculate on potential poisoning based on historical records detailing symptoms and circumstances surrounding various deaths.

The use of arsenic was not confined to the underworld; it found its way into the courts of French royalty and even the Vatican, where it was said enemies were dispatched under the direction of Pope Alexander VI Borgia. Even respectable households resorted to arsenic to settle inheritance disputes, earning it the moniker "poudre de succession."

Until the 1840s, this lethal substance appeared to be the perfect tool for crime—odorous, tasteless, and colorless, easily obtainable as rat poison. However, the tide began to turn as chemists took action against these unchecked poisoners, with notable contributions from two chemists separated by the English Channel.

James Marsh's Groundbreaking Techniques

In 1836, an article published in the "Edinburgh Philosophical Journal" marked a revolutionary moment in toxicology. Written by 42-year-old James Marsh, a chemist at the Royal Arsenal in Woolwich, the paper emerged during his tumultuous life marked by poverty, depression, and alcoholism.

The catalyst for Marsh's work was the mysterious death of a wealthy farmer near Woolwich. When police suspected poisoning, they ordered an autopsy, securing the victim's coffee cup as critical evidence. Marsh was summoned as the only chemist available, despite his focus on naval artillery.

He began exploring arsenic detection methods developed by German pharmacologists. Marsh successfully identified arsenic compounds in the farmer's stomach contents, leading to the prosecution of the farmer's grandson, who had purchased arsenic as rat poison shortly before the incident.

However, the trial on December 12, 1832, ended in disappointment for Marsh; the jury dismissed his chemical evidence as insufficient, leading to the grandson's acquittal.

How Arsenic Went from Poison to Medicine - YouTube

This video explores the fascinating transition of arsenic from a notorious poison to a medicinal substance, shedding light on its complex history.

Test Against Poisoners

Offended by the trial's outcome, Marsh resolved to create a method that would withstand juror scrutiny. Inspired by German chemist Carl Scheele's work on arsine, he developed a U-shaped apparatus that would detect even trace amounts of arsenic in liquids. This innovation produced arsine gas, which, when ignited, left behind distinctive dark spots on porcelain.

The impact of Marsh's findings was profound, raising hopes that poisoners would face justice. Yet, despite advancements, poisoners continued to evade capture, and the 1851 British law aimed at regulating arsenic sales had limited effectiveness.

Mathieu Orfila and the Birth of Modern Toxicology

Meanwhile, across the English Channel, Mathieu Joseph Bonaventure Orfila was waging his own battle against poisoners. Initially aspiring to be a sailor, he turned to chemistry, studying independently before earning his medical degree in Paris in 1811.

Orfila established a laboratory in his apartment, where he conducted experiments on animals to deepen the understanding of poisons. His work culminated in influential publications that solidified his reputation as a leading figure in forensic toxicology.

As arsenic claimed more lives, Orfila dedicated his research to uncovering its effects. Through experiments, he demonstrated that arsenic could be traced in organs long after its ingestion, complicating the landscape of forensic investigation.

The Lafarge Case: A Turning Point

On January 16, 1840, Judge Moran ordered an investigation into the arsenic levels in the remains of Charles Lafarge, a man who had fallen into financial ruin. He sought a wealthy bride to revive his fortunes, eventually marrying the orphan Marie Cappelle, who misrepresented her background.

Marie, disillusioned by their dire living conditions, concocted a plan involving arsenic-laced pancakes. After Charles fell gravely ill, suspicions arose when family members observed her suspicious behavior.

Following Charles's death, authorities discovered Marie's arsenic purchases, prompting an autopsy. Local doctors, lacking the latest techniques, mishandled the investigation, leading to a hasty conclusion of poisoning.

However, Marie's arrest came after a series of legal maneuvers led by her lawyer, who enlisted Orfila's expertise. In court, Orfila's advanced methodologies revealed errors in the earlier examinations, ultimately confirming the presence of arsenic in Charles's body.

The Truth About Arsenic in the Victorian Era - YouTube

This video delves into the societal implications of arsenic use during the Victorian era, examining its dual role as both a poison and a medicinal compound.

A New Era in Forensic Science

Marie Lafarge was sentenced to life in prison, symbolizing a victory for toxicology over crime. While Orfila couldn't oversee every poisoning trial, the Lafarge case ignited a fervent interest in poison detection methods.

Medical professionals and budding scientists began flocking to Orfila, eager to unravel the complexities of forensic toxicology. This marked the dawn of a new era in the field, forever altering the landscape of crime and justice.