Starting with Common Ground

Whether one identifies as a Christian or not, most would agree that Christ's death had a significant purpose. His life and death were not in vain.

So, what was the purpose?

In the diverse spectrum of Christianity, a consensus appears to exist among various groups—both liberal and conservative—that Jesus’s crucifixion somehow reconciled humanity with God. This process is referred to as atonement, a term that signifies peace-making or harmony.

If you were to approach any of the two billion Christians worldwide and inquire about atonement, you’d likely receive an affirmative response, accompanied by a knowing smile.

This is where perspectives begin to diverge.

While Christ’s death may have facilitated a reconciliation between God and humanity, the exact nature of that reconciliation varies. Here are several differing viewpoints:

The First Perspective: Jesus as a Bargaining Chip

Initially, for the first millennium of Christianity, many believed that humanity was imprisoned by Satan due to the original sin in the Garden of Eden.

In this scenario, Jesus becomes the ultimate bargaining tool, offered to Satan as payment for humanity's release. Only Jesus's pure and innocent soul could serve as the acceptable currency for reconciling humanity with the Father.

Satan, unaware that Jesus possessed both human and divine nature, was shocked when Christ emerged victorious from the depths of Hell after three days, returning to His rightful place in Heaven, while Satan was left defeated.

The Ransom Theory of atonement finds strong biblical support in Jesus's own words: “Just as the Son of Man came not to be served but to serve and to give His life as a ransom for many” (Matthew 20:28), with similar sentiments echoed in Mark 10:45 and 1 Timothy 2:5–6.

You might find this concept a bit unusual, but the Ransom Theory was widely accepted among prominent thinkers of the time. Historical context reveals that hostage situations and ransom demands were common, making the theory more relatable.

Yet, not everyone endorses the Ransom Theory, as critics argue it undermines God's sovereignty. Why, they question, would God need to pay anything to Satan? This leads us to another theory.

The Second Perspective: A Debt to God

The notion of God owing a debt to Satan presented theological challenges. Thus, in the 11th century, Anselm of Canterbury introduced a new idea.

In his theory, it was humanity that owed a debt to God, not the other way around. Our sins offended God's honor, and this offense required restitution, something humanity, being inferior, could not achieve alone. Christ's sacrifice served as a mediator, allowing for the restoration of God’s honor.

Anselm’s perspective was shaped by the feudal culture of his time, where relationships were built on obligations and honor. As both fully human and fully divine, Jesus could restore that honor—effectively a two-for-one solution.

The Third Perspective: Punishment for Our Sins

Fast forward five centuries post-Anselm, and during the Reformation, thinkers led by John Calvin pushed the narrative further.

For them, it wasn't merely about restoring God's honor; it was about justice. God, the ultimate judge, could not let human sin go unpunished. This gave rise to the Penal Substitutionary Theory of Atonement—what I learned in Sunday school.

In this view, God sent His Son to take on the punishment intended for us. Sound familiar?

Critics of this theory argue it depicts God as a temperamental figure who needs a scapegoat, raising questions about why the Creator would demand death for transgressions.

Theologian James Beilby critiques both Anselm’s and Calvin’s portrayals of God, suggesting they reflect a punitive deity rather than one of love and grace.

The Fourth Perspective: An Example of Love

Another thinker from Anselm’s era, Peter Abelard, proposed a different approach, known as the Moral Influence Theory of Atonement.

Abelard suggested that Christ's life and death showcase the depth of God’s love, which in itself can draw humanity back to Him. This theory emphasizes that God does not need to be appeased for forgiveness; rather, the issue lies within humanity’s own hardened hearts.

Supporters of this view cite 1 Peter 2:22, which encourages believers to follow Christ's example.

However, critics argue this theory fails to address the fundamental question of what we need saving from.

The Fifth Perspective: Cosmic Victory

In the modern era, theologian Gustaf Aulén introduced the Christus Victor theory in the 1930s. This view suggests a cosmic battle between good and evil, with Christ as the conqueror who engages in this struggle.

Aulén's theory emphasizes that Jesus’s mission was to reclaim humanity from Satan’s grasp, focusing on universal reconciliation rather than individual salvation.

Despite its grand narrative, questions arise about how the Cross serves as the instrument of evil's defeat and why humanity still grapples with sin.

The Challenge of Definitive Answers

The desire for a straightforward answer is inherently human. Interestingly, all the theories presented can find support in various biblical passages.

There are many more theories beyond those discussed here, and they often reveal cracks under scrutiny—demonstrating the complexity of understanding atonement.

If pressed for my own perspective, I would say, “I see elements of truth in all of them, yet none fully encapsulate the entirety of the matter.” It’s akin to grasping smoke; the subject is intricate and multifaceted.

Beware those who claim to have definitive answers; they may overlook the nuances inherent in such a profound mystery.

What we are left with is a divine mystery that invites faith in the unseen and the unknown. Rather than attempting to explain it all, perhaps we should embrace the wonder of what is.

Note: This article is an excerpt from "Leaving Church, Finding God: Discovering Faith Beyond Organized Religion."

The Backyard Church is more than a blog; it’s a community for those who have faith but may feel disconnected from traditional church settings. Join us today.

New to Medium? Click here to become a member and gain access to this and countless other articles.

For more insights on life, faith, and spirituality, subscribe to my newsletter or send questions and story ideas to [email protected].