Exploring the Efficacy of AI Headline Generators: My Findings
Written on
Chapter 1: Introduction to AI in Headline Generation
Recently, I embarked on a journey to experiment with various headline creation techniques to enhance my readership while maintaining authenticity and steering clear of clickbait. A recommendation I encountered on Medium was to utilize a website that could generate headlines on my behalf.
Image by Wanicon, edited on Canva
Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools for content creation have become increasingly popular, encompassing AI writers, automation tools, and image creators. Among these innovations is the AI headline generator, which utilizes extensive databases along with user prompts to devise catchy headlines.
Section 1.1: Challenges with AI in Current Trends
AI writing tools often struggle with contemporary subjects, recent trends, or complex societal discussions. For example, when I inquired about "quiet quitting," the AI's output was quite underwhelming. Although these tools access vast amounts of data, I anticipated they would remain updated with the latest trends.
Subsection 1.1.1: Lack of Contextual Understanding
When tasked with generating an impactful headline regarding "AI Writer," the AI produced the following suggestions:
- How AI Writer Rescued My Marriage
- The Most Dull Article About AI Writer You’ll Ever Read
- 8 Tricks to Overcome Your Worst AI Writer Habits
- The Devastating Effects of COVID-19 on AI Writer
- 5 Astonishing Facts About AI Writer
Apart from the last suggestion, the rest were largely nonsensical and unusable. This pattern persisted with other AI writing tools I tested, which yielded even poorer results.
Photo by Kaitlyn Baker on Unsplash
Section 1.2: The Quest for Originality
Admittedly, this challenge is not exclusive to AI. Popular platforms like Buzzfeed showcase a plethora of titles that, while varied in topic, often reveal a repetitive nature upon closer examination. Typical headlines might include:
- 9 Habits of Highly Successful Individuals
- I Challenge You Not to Laugh at These Facebook Comments
- 15 Most Nostalgic Films from the 90s
Although such titles may capture some clicks, they rarely foster a dedicated readership. Modern readers tend to skim through content, aiming to reach the images, quotes, or lists highlighted in the title. When analyzing the headlines from top writers on Medium or other sites, one can identify certain patterns—such as the use of numbers, lists, and emotionally charged words—while still maintaining uniqueness. It's essential for titles to be attention-grabbing, promise value, and remain transparent without resorting to clickbait tactics.
Chapter 2: Conclusion on AI Headline Generators
While headline generators can propose a multitude of catchy title options, it's crucial not to be misled by the sheer volume. These suggestions often lack originality, relevance, and contextual awareness. Personally, I’ve decided to refrain from using AI headline generators in the near future.