E. Jean Carroll vs. Donald Trump: A Deep Dive into Animal Societies
Written on
Chapter 1: The Verdict's Significance
The recent verdict in the E. Jean Carroll versus Donald Trump case transcends legal implications; it touches on profound insights derived from the study of animal societies. For many who have dedicated their lives to observing these societies, it comes as no surprise that a courageous 80-year-old woman has successfully challenged a notorious liar and sexual predator, a man whose appointments to the judiciary have systematically undermined women's rights over their own bodies. This landmark ruling marks a significant moment of financial accountability for Trump, reflecting the potential for many more such reckonings to come. Women everywhere are heralding Carroll’s statement in court: “He is nothing,” as she urged others to shed their fear of him.
Section 1.1: Insights from Animal Societies
There is a deeper narrative woven into this ruling, one that can be elucidated by examining various animal societies. Observations of primate behavior have revealed that the traditional notion of alpha males as dominant figures is flawed. Renowned primatologist Barbara Smuts uncovered that female baboons often dictate mating choices, favoring males who engage in nurturing behaviors, such as caring for young. Similarly, Jane Goodall’s extensive studies of chimpanzees illustrate how powerful matriarchs, like Fifi, cultivate confident and capable leaders.
Subsection 1.1.1: The Wisdom of Orcas
Consider the matriarchal orca whales who skillfully guide their family groups. Interestingly, male orcas typically have shorter lifespans than their female counterparts and remain with their mothers throughout their lives, whereas females often establish their own pods. Recent research from the University of Exeter highlights that menopause, observed in only six species including humans and certain toothed whales, may confer evolutionary advantages.
Post-menopausal orca matriarchs play a pivotal role within their families, often living up to 90 years and outlasting males by an average of 22 years. Their longevity significantly benefits their male offspring, shielding them from threats. As noted by BBC science writer Victoria Gill, male orcas rely heavily on their mothers, even going so far as to demand a share of their catches. The sacrifices made by these matriarchs are substantial; research indicates that the survival rate of their calves diminishes significantly if the mother dies.
Section 1.2: The Role of Female Elders in Animal Society
As more women engage in long-term studies of animal behavior, they increasingly document the crucial roles females play in various species—from matriarchal elephants and orcas to the sisterhoods of hyenas. Lucy Cooke, in her acclaimed work "Bitch: On the Female of the Species," explores the complex social structures and adaptive strategies of female animals. She argues that our leaders could greatly benefit from embodying the qualities of these wise and nurturing matriarchs.
Chapter 2: Lessons for Humanity
Drawing parallels between matriarchal structures in nature and the current political landscape, we must acknowledge the importance of female elders like E. Jean Carroll, who bravely confront the bullies of our time. Donald Trump's theatrics may impress a select group, but the true path to our collective survival lies in the wisdom of matriarchs.
Women are now at the forefront of holding Trump accountable for his history of misogyny. The names of these women—Cassidy Hutchison, Liz Cheney, and E. Jean Carroll—will be etched in both history and herstory. As the demographic landscape of the U.S. shifts, the traditional bastions of power may soon crumble under the weight of change.
The ongoing reflection on why some women align with patriarchal structures may stem from a desire to be associated with perceived winners. However, as the tide turns against figures like Trump, we must consider alternative alliances. Will women, like baboons, ultimately choose camaraderie and support over dominance?
Power dynamics are ever-changing. Outrage and retribution are not sustainable solutions; they distract us from the serious challenges that lie ahead. Unlike animals, who adapt to their environments without denial, we must embrace change.
The era of American patriarchy is waning, making way for a matriarchal dawn. The transition may be arduous and require sacrifices, yet we possess the evolutionary advantage necessary for adaptation. This is the essence of survival in the animal kingdom, and it is a lesson we must heed.
Bio: Brenda Peterson is an author and novelist, with over 20 published works, including the New York Times Notable Book "Duck and Cover" and the acclaimed "Wolf Nation." Her latest book, "Wild Chorus: Finding Harmony with Whales, Wolves, and Other Animals," explores the interconnectedness of wildlife and humanity.